Transgenic Mustard (DMH-11) in India
India is one of the world’s largest consumers of edible oil, yet it imports more than 60% of its total demand, making it highly dependent on global markets. Mustard (rapeseed) is the country’s second-most important oilseed crop after soybean, and improving its yield is seen as a strategic step toward reducing import dependency.
The University of Delhi’s Centre for Genetic Manipulation of Crop Plants (CGMCP), led by Dr. Deepak Pental, spearheaded the development of Dhara Mustard Hybrid-11 (DMH-11), a transgenic hybrid mustard variety.
The Innovation
-
Technology Used:
-
DMH-11 was created using the barnase-barstar-bar gene system.
-
This system enables the production of high-yielding hybrid mustard seeds by preventing self-pollination and allowing cross-pollination between parent lines.
-
-
Yield Gains:
-
Field trials suggest 20–30% higher yields compared to conventional mustard varieties.
-
Higher productivity could directly boost domestic edible oil production.
-
-
Development Timeline:
-
Research began in 2002, with nearly 14 years of R&D before regulatory submissions.
-
It has since undergone confined field trials, bio-safety testing, and regulatory evaluations.
-
Economic & Market Significance
-
India’s Edible Oil Deficit:
-
India imports ~14–15 million tonnes of edible oil annually, costing over USD 10–12 billion.
-
A successful rollout of DMH-11 could reduce import dependency and support farmer income.
-
-
Farmer Benefits:
-
Higher yields → improved profitability.
-
Reduced vulnerability to global oilseed price shocks.
-
-
Potential Market Impact:
-
Could stimulate domestic oilseed processing industries.
-
May encourage the adoption of GM technologies in other food crops if successful.
-
Policy & Regulatory Journey
-
Regulatory Hurdles:
-
The Genetic EngineeringAppraisal Committee (GEAC) cleared DMH-11 for environmental release in 2017, but commercialization was delayed due to legal challenges and public protests.
-
In October 2022, GEAC again recommended environmental release, renewing debates around GM crops.
-
-
Opposition & Concerns:
-
Environmental groups and farmer unions argue GM mustard could harm biodiversity, threaten native mustard varieties, and increase dependence on multinational seed companies.
-
Health & Environmental Safety: Concerns raised about pesticide resistance and long-term ecological impacts, despite official biosafety trials indicating safety.
-
-
Government Stance:
-
The Indian government has positioned DMH-11 as a strategic tool for food security and import substitution, though political and judicial challenges persist.
-
Environmental & Social Dimensions
-
Biodiversity Concerns: Potential cross-pollination with wild relatives could threaten genetic purity.
-
Pesticide Debate: Critics fear GM mustard may increase the use of herbicides like glufosinate.
-
Food Sovereignty: Debate centers around seed sovereignty, whether farmers will remain dependent on proprietary seeds or benefit from public-sector innovation (since DMH-11 is developed by a public university, not a multinational corporation).
Future Outlook
-
Commercialization Path: If DMH-11 clears final legal and regulatory hurdles, it could be India’s first commercially approved food GM crop, after Bt cotton (fiber) and Bt brinjal (which remains under moratorium).
-
Scaling Impact: Adoption across mustard-growing states like Rajasthan, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh could significantly raise domestic edible oil production.
-
Policy Ripple Effects: Success of DMH-11 may open doors for other transgenic food crops (rice, wheat, pulses), accelerating India’s entry into modern agri-biotech.
Key Takeaways
-
DMH-11 represents a milestone in Indian GM crop research—14 years of R&D in a public institution.
-
It promises 20–30% higher yields, addressing India’s USD 10–12 billion edible oil import bill.
-
The project faces regulatory, legal, and social resistance, particularly around biosafety, biodiversity, and seed sovereignty.
-
If approved for commercialization, DMH-11 could reshape India’s GM crop policy and spark wider biotech adoption.
-
Its outcome will influence the future of food security, farmer livelihoods, and biotechnology regulation in India.